web analytics
Your Independent Alternative!

It’s Not Polite, But It’s Democracy

MitchI have no illusions about those protesters at recent town hall meetings on health care.

Some are fueled by angry conservative groups. Some are hopped up on radio hosts' rants and ravings. Some are Barack Obama haters. Some use one piece of wrong information to smear an entire event.

And some -- maybe even most -- just think the whole idea of government health care stinks.

But all of them -- all of them -- have the right to be there, and the right to their point of view. Liberal-minded thinkers who regularly speak up for the poor and underprivileged cannot suddenly yank the rug when it comes to free speech for others.

No matter what I think of national health care -- no matter what you think, either -- it is an issue that affects everyone, and everyone should have the same right to talk, argue or shout about it.

The fact that some are doing so in an impolite, abrasive way is unfortunate.

But then, there is precedent.

The golden era of protests

Let's be honest. Those of us who grew up in the 1960s took great pride in storming events and yelling slogans. We didn't care who we interrupted. We were, in our minds, right and proud and arguing for our beliefs. And we look back on that era now with a certain pride. We were engaged. We were involved. We gave a damn.

Well, some of us are the same people now offended by critics shouting "Socialism!" or "Kill the bill!" at these town hall meetings. We chide the protesters for lacking all the facts or only looking out for their small group's interests.

But ask yourself, did we always have all the information when we did the shouting? Not really. Did we always read all the fine print? Probably not. We had our basic core beliefs (Stop the war! Save the environment! More rights for women!) and we fought for them whenever we perceived an enemy.

Well, like it or not, people perceive an enemy when they hear about a government health care plan. Especially one so complex, confusing and undercooked that no one can really say what it will or won't allow, or who will or won't pay for it.

And so they yell. And if they are yelling incorrect facts, it is the burden of those hosting these events (usually Democratic lawmakers) to correct them.

And if they are yelling they hate it, they don't want it -- well, what's wrong with that?

The price of democracy

Now, I know some of these protesters are nudged there by dubiously named groups like Americans for Prosperity, which sounds harmless enough, until you check and see the group's leader once organized for Enron and worked with disgraced lobbyist Jack Abramoff.

And I know some people just want to see Obama fail, and destroying his health care baby would be a good first step.

But that's what America is. That's what town halls are for. The only problem I have is when people won't let others speak or only come to disrupt. That's not right. That's not democracy.

But the rest is. If you feel other people are ill informed, take the time to try to correct them. If you feel others are shouting to bring down a cause, shout to bring it up.

But I would rather live in a place where people questioned what their government proposed rather than swallowing it blindly -- especially a government whose members guard our tax money while taking bribes, shout morality and then get caught with their pants down, or lecture businessmen about private planes and then order a bunch for themselves.

What did Democrats expect with a bill like this? Roses and hosannas? Many who supported Obama's campaign promises of health care for everyone wouldn't have done so if they read how he now plans to pay for it and administer it.

It may not be pretty, but shouting and confrontations are part of this country and have been from the start. More manners would be better. But silence would be worse.

(C) 2009 BY THE DETROIT FREE PRESS DISTRIBUTED BY TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.

2 Responses »

  1. The media and Congress are too sterile and too politically correct today to understand real emotions. So unless it has to do with sex and violence on the movie scene the media doesn't know how to handle real protest by real citizens. Congress and media have gone their own way for years without listening to the "real" American folk out there. Well, now they are getting an ear full and they don't know how to handle it. They don't like it. My Senator from Florida doesn't listen; he writes back the "party line" unpersonal lengthy wordy nonsense replies. He will get it when he is up for reelection.

  2. Those of us who grew up in the 1960s shrieking slogans and acting-out in mindless protest made public asses of ourselves. In doing so, we created a political backlash that impedes reform politics to this very day. Is that what town-hall disrupters hope to create for their own politics of resistance?

    Shouting-down those with whom you disagree is undemocratic. It is the kind of thuggish behavior that poisons democracy and leads to fascism. It offends every thoughtful citizen trying to see into the future of a complicated world.